Square or rectangle, decide first

Decide on the shape first. A tight square crop flatters one or two faces, so it suits portraits and pets, and the shop carries square sizes for that. A 2 by 3 inch rectangle keeps the proportions of a phone photo, so groups and wide scenes stay whole. If you pick the shape before the photo, you won't end up cramming a lineup into a square that cuts the ends off.

Crop tight, then check it small

In custom work, the crop matters more than anything else. Trim to the subject, drop the distracting background, and leave a little clean space if a name or date is going on. Then shrink the image on your phone until it is about the size of the finished magnet. If the faces still read at that size, it will print well. If the subject melts into the background, crop harder or pick another frame.

Add a label, not a paragraph

Text is part of customizing, but a little goes a long way. A first name, a year, or a short phrase adds something to a photo, particularly across a set covering several children. A full sentence crowds a small piece and, oddly, makes it feel less personal. If there is more to say, put it in the card that travels with the gift, where there is room to write it out.

Build it around the person, not the date

It's easy to design around a birthday or a holiday, but the sets people hold on to are usually built around a relationship. A set for a sibling in another city might lean on places you both remember. One for a new grandparent might gather the faces they see least often. Ask what this particular person would want to look at every morning, then choose photos that answer that question, whatever the calendar says.

Keeping a large run consistent

An order of dozens or hundreds only looks deliberate if the pieces match. Reuse one palette, one layout, and one type style so a table of favors or a stack of save-the-dates looks like one set instead of a collection of separate ideas. Lock the template before you scale up. Count the guest list before ordering, then add spares for plus-ones, helpers, and the few that vanish into goodie bags.

Order a set, plus a few spares

Few people order single custom photo magnets. Most order a small set built around one person or one stretch of time. Six covers a gift, and nine fills a grid or splits between two homes. Add a couple of spares, because the first person who sees them on a fridge usually asks for their own. The product options guide compares the material and finish choices on the order form.